Friday, January 18, 2013

Adoption and the Church

Whew.  That's a BIG title and I'm not sure if this weeny post will live up to it but here goes...

Since we began adopting, I've looked long and hard to find out what exactly the Catholic church teaches about adoption specifically - to not much avail.  Come to think of it, that might be why I started this blog - as a place to explore all the facets of it.  I understood that the Catechism clearly teaches that infertility is a heavy cross to bear and that there are a number of options in ways to carry it.  I also was able to understand her teachings on the inherent gift and dignity of children and why we shouldn't purposefully conceive them in a disordered manner (any method not involving the marital embrace).  The church also abhors abortion at all stages (and the destruction of embryos) for obvious reasons.  It is also clear from scripture that Christians are challenged to care for orphans as well as "love our neighbors as ourselves".  Catholic marriages are to be models of generosity and should bear good fruit in the form of works or children or both.

Yet our culture still sometimes holds onto anti-adoption attitudes - even, dare I say, in the pro-life community.  The taboo is two-fold and exists on both sides of the coin:  adopting a child and placing a child for adoption.  It is truly confounding to me why our society, in general, seems to accept the immoral choices of artificial fertility "treatment" (for infertility) and abortion (for unplanned pregnancies), while shunning a perfectly moral option for both:  adoption.  Often both of these situations do not send the "average Joe" looking for exactly what the Church teaches on it and instead they resort to reflex - the quick fix, what everyone else does, make it stop, get me my life back, I want, I want, I want...I didn't want...

Here's the way I see it.  Infertility is a disorder.  It's cause, so often unknown and unexplained and complex is not natural.  Whether it's a consequence from the "fall of man" like some kind of illness we just don't know.  Most unplanned pregnancies are also disordered.  I'm not talking about the surprise baby for the married couple here, I'm talking about unmarried, uncommitted, sexual union resulting in the conception of a child.

Both of these disordered situations create moral quandaries for us.
What to do?
What does God want us to do?

Well we know what he doesn't want us to do, right?  Kill. Demean. Offend.  Lie.  Compound the disorder.

But. He doesn't really tell us exactly what to do either does He? And this makes so much sense to me because God loves freedom and speaking to our hearts, and above all His desire is for us to choose the good - even if it costs us. Some of us will feel called to, in a sense, "restore order" by giving a child a family he or she doesn't have.  Some of us will feel called to place a child in a stable family we know we are incapable of providing ourselves.  Some of us will feel called to suffer and offer our sufferings for a redemptive purpose.  Some of us will make the best of single parenting.  Some of us will spiritually adopt someone.  There just isn't one answer, but there is one answer for each of us...

and the ONLY way we will know it is to PRAY.
Pray unceasingly.
"Not my will Lord, but yours."
  

*again blogger is giving me the twitches, forgive editing errors por favor!

7 comments:

  1. Yup, yup and yup. I've heard some people call adoption "a necessary evil" which I bristle at until you think about the fallen state of the human condition. In a perfect world--the world that He created in the first place--neither orphans nor infertility would exist. But it does and adoption can provide a solution to both.

    The issue is so complex though and since it always begins with a loss and tragedy, it's probably very difficult to make a formal declaration about it without offending, appearing to marginalize one group or other or perhaps even implicitly approve of sinful behavior somehow. (Much like the quandary of what to do with all the frozen embyros sitting in cryogenesis around the world). Would the Church then have to decide whether or not infertile couples are *obliged* to adopt? I know some very good theologians who argue (strongly) that yes...we are obliged but *I* don't see the Church is demanding it. Difficult stuff indeed on all sides.

    For now, it's good enough for me that Scripture and tradition exhort us to care for the orphans and trudge ahead guided by prayer.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yep...

    Just discussed this with a friend yesterday. That while I'm glad to see more Catholics stepping out to adopt, we still have a long way to go. It seems like the non-Catholics were actively pro-adoption and we Catholics were actively pro-life, and I am hoping we can all become stronger in whichever part we are not.

    Also, though, even after months of prayer and discernment, we still don't feel like we have complete support of our Catholic community by taking the leap. Hoping that will change, too.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I love all your thoughts on this. I have to admit that I never considered how others view adoption. We have not adopted, but it is not uncommon in our extended family. I guess I took it as a matter of course that it is a wonderful thing.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks, Danya. It helps to know that there might not be a clear answer to what exactly the Church teaches on adoption. I read your thoughts with great interest, and then your wrap-up said just what I needed to hear:

    “There just isn't one answer, but there is one answer for each of us...
    and the ONLY way we will know it is to PRAY. Pray unceasingly.
    "Not my will Lord, but yours."”

    The prayer most often on my lips during our four year journey to add to our family and especially during our agonizing two-week period of waiting for all of our adoption’s legal issues to play out was simply “Thy will be done.” (At first not because of any particular spiritual maturity on my part but rather because a creative priest once required as penance that I plant myself in front of the Blessed Sacrament and pray those four words exclusively over and over again. As I continued to pray those four words over the course of several months, I gradually came to truly mean them, which did eventually lead to a greatly improved level of trust in God’s plan for the life of my family. Pretty clever priest…)

    In the end, our call to our adopted son has been repeatedly confirmed in ways that only God can accomplish, and that’s what I need to hold on to as the Church and the pro-life community appear to equivocate.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I needed this today, Danya. We have been blessed with two beautiful, healthy boys, but have struggled significantly to have more children (three heartbreaking miscarriages in 13 months). Because of a partial molar, we are now in a waiting game until we can actively try to conceive without risking losing another precious baby. Our Lord has placed the idea of adoption very heavily onto my heart for many months now. But I must admit to being so overwhelmed by the length and cost of the process that I can not even bring myself to fill out the preliminary paperwork. I just don't know where to begin, if I'm being honest. Any tips you may have for us as to where to start would be so appreciated! rachelgabby@hotmail.com

    ReplyDelete

Comments release my dopamine.